August Business Insights with Cameron Bagrie

August 1, 2024

Last month’s theme, “bad news is setting the scene for good news,” continues. More evidence shows the economy is reversing, inflation is easing, and interest rate relief may come in 2024 instead of 2025.

However, beware the allure of magic potions; lower interest rates will not make New Zealand wealthier. Increased productivity is the key to prosperity. There’s a danger that the promise of better times will distract us from the hard work needed to cement those improvements.

Financial markets expect the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) to cut the Official Cash Rate (OCR) sooner rather than later. The driving force is pronounced economic weakness, with the RBNZ acknowledging “declining activity across the economy,” indicating another recession. Economic conditions have sharply deteriorated in recent months.

This recession differs from the mild ones of late 2022/early 2023 and the second half of 2023, when the economy contracted. Job losses are mounting as businesses cut costs, and new orders and sales are the biggest constraints for firms, not labour shortages. The economy now has spare capacity.

An economy with spare capacity leads to discounting and sharper pricing to maintain work volumes and shift stock. Pay expectations are easing as job insecurity rises. This is the disinflation scenario the RBNZ needed but did not see in 2023 or early 2024. Disinflation gives the RBNZ greater confidence that 2% inflation is within reach and brings the prospect of interest rate relief.

Prospects for lower interest rates have helped the New Zealand dollar decline, benefiting exporters at the expense of importers. We need a sustained period of a low currency to boost investment and confidence in the export sector.

Lower interest rates will not improve average daily school attendance from 83% in term two to the target of 94%. On the last day of term 2, 189,000 students were absent, equivalent to the population of Hamilton. “Friday-itis,” where students regularly take Friday off, is a problem that extends into the workforce.

Lower interest rates will reduce the finance cost of infrastructure but won’t improve management practices around our capital stock. Local government finances remain strained, and credit downgrades are occurring. Voters will voice displeasure with large rate increases, forcing exploration of other avenues to fix financial positions.

We won’t materially shift productivity if we don’t address competition policy, get the banking sector right so they both price for risk (margins and profit) but take risks (expressed as volatility of earnings), address infrastructure woes, and unlock natural endowments such as water and irrigation.

These are examples of policy areas that need boldness. Boldness is inversely proportional to tough times. Vangelis Vitalis, New Zealand’s chief trade negotiator, talks about the end of the golden era in trade. Protectionism is rising as the world fractures. We need to adapt if we are to double exports.

The business sector also needs to change. Xero’s latest small business insights data reported June 2024 sales were down 8.3% compared to June 2023. Meanwhile, wage growth and employment accelerated. Rising costs and declining revenues do not bode well for the bottom line. It smacks of complacency and waiting for things to come right.

New Zealand is entering a delicate stage. Enough pain has been inflicted that the appetite for change has risen, and we are seeing constructive movements in some key areas. Bring on the attack on the road cones!

There are also latent risks in our current position. Complacency sets in before enough of the job is done. Lower interest rates and expansionary fiscal policy (tax relief) are enough to lift growth in 2025. However, the allure of better times is not backed by real substance.

Real substance will only come from an all-out attack on improving productivity across the economy. For an example of how productivity works and its benefits, look no further than the United States. Inflation has eased, and it looks like the Federal Reserve will cut their interest rates before the RBNZ. Growth has averaged around 2% over the last 18 months. They have tamed inflation without excessive collateral damage. One key reason is rising productivity growth.

The bottom line is that magic potions in the form of interest rate relief will ultimately turn into snake oil if they divert us from the real task at hand: lifting productivity growth. The job is far from done. We are in round two of a twelve-round match.

Author
Cameron Bagrie
Share Article

Let's chat

Partner with us to achieve your financial goals and unlock your business growth potential.